Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I think Kev can now be considered fully match fit.
Clearly wanted to see it to the end on Saturday.I would not go that far yet, the body takes time to build up to full strength and it would be easy to push it too hard and see him suffer a muscle injury. I would not want to see him play a full 90 minutes yet, especially on the back of 80+ on Saturday, he’s too important for this team.
Plenty to welcome in there but the proof of the pudding will be in the eating.
We are talking about that, yes, but I have previously mentioned reading a game and the need for intelligence. A bit of leading by example is no bad thing.
I completely agree with you but that didn’t seem to be the point you were making earlier in the thread with phrases like “drill sargeant” and “bawling his lungs out”.
Having taught in both the state sector and the private – I can tell you that, for me, the single largest reason why state schools get poorer results is that the independent sector is considerably less tolerant of failure.
Having been educated in both systems, I think this is much more down to the high quality of teaching & other resources in the private sector. A class of 15 is a very different beast from a class of 30. The private sector probably demands higher standards and sets higher expectations but it also has a far greater chance of achieving them. Failure is relative.
Just shouting at people as a motivational tactic is antediluvian.
I still think that promotion in 2014 was under rated not least because Wilcox had to pick up Laws’ mess and cope with a huge number of new signings. Yes he had some good players and in Winnall we had a really reliable goalscorer but we had 14 players in and 10 players out that season, coming on the back of a terrible relegation season. It was a big achievement to get us up, no matter how it was done.
But it set a pattern for just continuously signing more players. How many youth team prospects have become first teamers in Swann’s time? Adelakun, you could argue, though he came through before Swann I think. Anyone else I’m missing? There must be someone!
It all sounded a bit amateurish to me.
Agreed. Which is why I thought there were some follow-up questions that Matt Dean should have asked of Swann but didn’t.
Hallam should be playing over Taylor, surely? No point in playing loanees if they’re no better than our own players.
I don’t get the British obsession with shouting in football. It is possible to show leadership & bravery in other ways.
2-1 win for the Iron, despite conceding an early penalty, again.
Loft to partner Fela, KvV to come off the bench and set up the winner.
So Watson up front then?
Given the stick he gets on here for his keeping, how many would disagree with that?
I thought Dean’s questions of Rob were fair, I thought he could have asked more questions of Swann.
I don’t think playing yet another player out of position is the answer.
Better than signing another player or sacking another manager which seem to be the other options being suggested?
Also, it gets him out of centre back where he’s not been great. Sometimes a player’s given position is not his best position.
Very well said. Hard to disagree with much of it.
I was confused why he mentioned the wage cap.
I agree that the midfield is the biggest problem at the moment but I don’t know how to go about settling that issue.
Maybe Bedeau could make a difference in midfield? I’ve not been impressed with him at centre back but he can play a bit and he could give us a bit of bite in there.
Essentially a reserve team fixture then? That makes more sense.
I have a theory that, at this level, the difference between a rubbish team and a title-winning team can just be having players who make a difference at each end of the pitch.
A really good keeper or centre-back and a really sharp (or Sharp?) striker and you can go from bumbling along to beating all-comers.
These difference-makers are so important because, ultimately, there is not much to choose between most teams at this level. So if you have a player who can take more chances than is normal or someone at the back who can stop more than is normal, you’ll turn a 0-1 defeat into a 1-1 draw or a 1-1 into a 2-1.
Who do we have that fits that bill? Van Veen? Possibly but I still think he’s best at making others look good rather than being deadly in front of goal. Eisa? Ditto. At the back? There aren’t really any candidates.
Has there ever been a more pointless match?
I’m genuinely interested in the thought process behind anyone who looks at the outcome of the last half a dozen manager sackings & thinks that sacking another manager will make a positive difference this time.
And I am sick of supporters saying “who is there to replace Cox,” the job wants advertising,
I would be interested to know who has been interviewed & rejected for the last few managerial appointments
I don’t understand praise of being “honest”, what does that mean? Are you expecting a summariser who tells us we’re 4-0 up and haven’t conceded a penalty for 6 months?
He tends to give several treatises on football for several minutes while the ball is in play and Mike White joins in as he feels he needs to agree
Agreed, he really belabours the point at times, it’s really boring!
Do people think Covid has made much difference to our league position (aside from the fact we’ve got games in hand) this season? Would it have been any different if this had been a normal season?
The second goal for Solihull might be the worst goal I’ve ever seen us concede.
First time I’ve heard him but I thought he was pretty poor, seems to only be able to talk about running & “hard work”. Nothing else seems to occur to him like confidence, skill, vision, organisation.
Basically, he commentates like he played.
Very fair point Deerey.
I must have missed something SanFran, what you driving at?
I love the FA Cup but it’s hard to think of a match I’ve been less arsed about, given the situation in the country, given the state of the club’s league position, given the daft kick-off time.
It’s a great story worth celebrating. I hope the model they’ve got isn’t wrecked by the pandemic.
I could be wrong but I wonder if they’re actually better set up to survive. Ask yourself this: if you had an actual stake in the club, would you consider chipping in to help it through the bad times? I think I’d be much more likely to do so.
I was reading elsewhere that Exeter are doing well because their outstanding youth academy has seen them receive some big transfer fees, including a chunky sell-on for the striker Brentford sold to Villa (Watkins?). Sure, some of that is lucky timing but it comes from doing things the right way.
As a ‘keeper he’ll still be approaching his peak though won’t he?
Sheffield United -> Bolton -> Blackpool -> Salford -> Us doesn’t really seem to say approaching a peak but let’s hope I’m wrong!
Spot on, out of the 30+ we have there are probably 7 or 8 that won’t figure in the match day squad unless we’re devastated by injury or Covid. Also some of those that make the squad will just be there to make up the numbers with little hope of getting on the pitch. A harsh assessment? Maybe but a genuine opinion nonetheless.
Do these players get paid?
It’s – what – four years since he was at Sheffield United though, isn’t it?
Sure, I understand in normal circumstances that fans would want more players but we have a squad of 30+ and we are currently not playing games in front of fans and we’re unlikely to do so for the rest of the season I would have thought.
I find it baffling that people are still thinking we should be signing even more players.
-
AuthorPosts