- This topic has 18 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 3 years, 5 months ago by
.
-
Whilst not wishing to disagree with one so erudite, surely if the marks 1,2,3,9 and 10 aren’t used we might as well use 1-5, with:
5: outstanding, once in a lifetime, game changing,
4: mom type performance,
3: average,
2: below average,
1: why was he picked?Can I start by rating the Swanns as a big round zero😅
3 users thanked author for this post.
You can give swann whatever mark you want Alcy, But it’s lesgeo’s thread let’s stick to his suggestion to keep everyone on the same track.
1 user thanked author for this post.
I have done rating marks on Scunthorpe matches for a few years, and consider them to be fair in general, and probably 90% of my marks fall into the scale talked about by Lesgeo, but in my opinion different supporters have slightly different views on players than other fans, so although it is impossible for all to give the same rating marks, it would also be pointless doing it in the first place.
For example I gave rating marks of 4 to both Rowe and O’Malley in last nights match, simply because they both had very poor games in my opinion, I class 5 or 6 as average marks, but their performances last night fell lower than average, so a 4 in my opinion suggests that there is room for improvement, so if you do not agree, just please pass on, or issue your own rating marks.
It is in my opinion very difficult to just use marks of 5-6-7 and 8, I often give a 9, and some times a 4, last night I had two ratings of 4, and just the one rating mark of 9 for the Ref who I thought was outstanding on the night.Interesting to read the views of other supporters.
“At the start of the season, I am hoping that we can all come to some sort of consensus on marking players, refs, managers, chairmen etc. All singing from the same team list?”
How dull. Posters are not professional markers, this forum is NOT a newspaper or a mag, and is anyone keeping a record of everyone’s marks (are you?). If they are they’ve got some catching up to do because BS is the only one to have provided any marks in 1 out of 3 games!!
Supporters marks are gut reactions and if players perform like they have no right to have a professional contract, then 0-4 are definitely fair marks.
2 users thanked author for this post.
You can give swann whatever mark you want Alcy, But it’s lesgeo’s thread let’s stick to his suggestion to keep everyone on the same track.
Les started it, I offered an amendment.
Isn’t that what the forum is about? Or does the thread starter’s opinion rule?
If so, I’ve a few more threads up my sleeve which no-one can then be allowed to argue with.
Good idea Awaywego?1 user thanked author for this post.
That’s fine Alcy, may I suggest using letters A to F the same as in A levels.
1 user thanked author for this post.
Have not done any marking for a while as I don’t think marking players on the fairly limited view you get on iFollow is particularly fair.
For all I know Green might have made 5 killer runs into dangerous positions and not had the ball passed to him. If that was the case he deserves a 6 or 7.
Based on what he did with the ball on screen he deserves a 4 or 5.
If I’m at the game then I’m prepared to give my views as you get the full picture. That aside Lesgeo’s comments seem sensible to me but this board is nothing without different opinions.
I don’t know what the hell happened there ha ha!, but just to complete that statement, The News of the World reports that they published on a Sunday, I often wondered if their reporters had actually been at some of the matches, so in my opinion, it is nice to read the supporters different views on their teams and players performances.
MK Iron—–I think that the view of matches on IFollower are pretty good mate, and often better than sitting in my old I32 seat in the Cluggy Stand, when having to peer round RSJ roof support columns, surely the cover is good enough to assess what is happening, plus the added input from Mike White and Tom Newey, I am normally in 98% agreement in what they are seeing and saying, they are first class in their views.
Probably just shows we all have different opinions and life would be dull if we didn’t.
If any other supporter takes their time to post their views and marking on a game, then I will certainly take the time to read them.
3 users thanked author for this post.
Probably just shows we all have different opinions and life would be dull if we didn’t.
If any other supporter takes their time to post their views and marking on a game, then I will certainly take the time to read them.
Me too, I am most grateful for the insight.
1 user thanked author for this post.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.